Learning to Discern: Is Misbehavior Really Sin?

Hey, fellow moms! Joy here! Today, I want to dive into a topic that has been weighing on my heart lately: misbehavior in our children, and whether or not it should be considered as sin. As a mom of five girls, ranging from toddler to pre-teen, I see a lot of misbehavior and as a Christian I am well aware of sin. But, is all of my children’s misbehavior because of their sinful nature? I’m sure this question resonates with many of you.

This may contain some affiliate links, which means I receive a small commission, at no extra cost to you, if you make a purchase using these links. For more information, please see my disclosure policy.

Before we jump in, I want to make it clear that there is no one-size-fits-all answer to this question. Every child is unique, and their behavior should be viewed through the lens of their development and capabilities. Sure, there are instances where our children do display sinful behavior, but more often than not, what we perceive as misbehavior may actually be a result of our unrealistic expectations.

Let me paint a picture for you. Imagine placing a newborn baby on the ground and demanding that they walk. Logically, we know that it’s impossible for them to do so at that stage. However, if the baby doesn’t comply, we don’t consider it misbehavior. We know we are asking something they are not capable of. As they grow, we sometimes forget this. We have to remember that developmentally appropriate expectations play a crucial role in determining whether a behavior is truly disobedience or simply an unrealistic demand.

As parents, we sometimes ask things of our children that they are not physically or developmentally capable of doing consistently. We want our three-year-olds to sit still and be quiet for an hour at church, forgetting that their natural curiosity and need for movement are all part of their God-given design. It’s important to recognize that expecting them to behave as miniature adults is both unfair and unrealistic.

It’s easy to fall into the trap of assuming that certain behaviors are sinful when, in fact, our children are simply communicating their needs in the best way they know how. Take the example of a whiny child. Rather than labeling their behavior as sinful, consider that they may be trying to express unmet needs or seeking attention in the only way they know will garner a response. Instead of writing it off as disobedience, let’s listen and seek to understand their struggles.

Now, don’t misunderstand me. I firmly believe in teaching our children about self-discipline and self-control. As they grow and learn, they will undoubtedly develop these skills. However, we need to acknowledge that emotional regulation and impulse control are still developmental milestones that our children are actively working towards. It’s not fair to impose adult expectations on young minds still learning to navigate their own emotions.

As parents, it’s crucial for us to evaluate our own expectations before labeling our children’s behavior as sin. Are we setting realistic goals that align with their developmental stage? Are we creating environments that support their growth? It’s vital that we recognize our own role in this dynamic and take responsibility for setting our children up for success.

Believe me, I’m right there in the trenches with you. As a mom, I’m constantly learning, growing, and being challenged by the Holy Spirit to reassess my own expectations. There have been times when I’ve asked my children to do something they’ve accomplished once, assuming they can do it consistently. But I’ve come to realize that their capabilities may vary, and that’s okay.

We have the privilege of witnessing our children’s growth in wisdom, stature, favor with God, and favor with man, just as Jesus did during his earthly journey (Luke 2:52). Let’s embrace the fact that growth takes time and that our children will stumble along the way. Instead of hastily labeling their misbehavior as sin, let’s approach it with grace, understanding, and a commitment to guide them towards maturity.

In conclusion, misbehavior isn’t always synonymous with sin. By considering our children’s developmental stage and expectations, we can discern whether their behavior is a result of unrealistic demands or genuine disobedience. Let’s be patient, supportive, and attentive parents who foster an environment of growth and understanding for our precious little ones.

Remember, we’re all in this together. Let’s lean on the Holy Spirit as our guide, learn from our own experiences, and embrace the joy of parenting with Jesus.

Join me on social media: